Even people who don’t care or don’t have any knowledge (or don’t care to have any knowledge) about real estate know the terms “Foreclosure” and “Short Sale”.
A quick and dirty definition of each:
A foreclosure is when a home owner is unable to pay their monthly payments any more and after a period of non-payment, the bank or other lending institution takes possession back of the property. At this point it is normally put on the market for sale or will go to auction to be sold.
A short sale is the period just before foreclosure when a home owner (sometimes working with their lending institution) tries to sell a home for an amount near what is left on the loan so that the owner can effectively get out from under it.
Now, let me preface what I am about to say with this: My opinion has been formed by the foreclosures and short sales that I have seen over the past ten or so years in my area. Thus, this is the case in the economic and real estate market is central West Virginia. Does this apply to your area or the area where you would like to invest? If not, feel free to ignore me.
Foreclosures simply take too long
As an example, I know of a house just a few miles from where I live. I knew the person who lived there and I knew when he lost his job. After attempting to make the payments that he could not afford, he eventually stopped. After at least a year of not making any payments, he moved out. The bank did not change the locks and kept the utilities on. Eventually they agreed to allow for him to attempt to sell the property as a short sale. There were offers, but the bank consistently took weeks to respond to any correspondence and would not accept or counter any offers. Eventually the listing expired and the house continued to sit there, unoccupied for three years. The utilities were turned off at some point. By the time this house came back on the market as a bank owned foreclosure, it was much worse condition than it was when the previous owner moved out. The gutters are clogged, which has led to water pooling and seeping into the downstairs living area and garage. It is infested with bugs and has several broken windows. This house, when it was first returned to the bank, only needed minor upkeep and repairs. Now, almost five years later, it needs upwards of $30,000 in repairs to make it a suitable home to live in.
So, overall, my complaint is that by the time a house actually comes on the market as a foreclosure any issues that it had have now been exacerbated by it sitting vacant for years. Not only does this make it much more difficult for someone like myself to make the needed repairs and still make money off of the flip, but it hurts the values of properties near it in the meantime. In the years that house has sits there becoming rundown and dilapidated, it becomes an eyesore that no one wants to live near. Are there squatters living there? Are there people using it to do or deal drugs? Would you be willing to let your child play outside your house when you don’t have these answers about the house next door?
Thus far, we have bought one actual foreclosure. We have tried to purchase quite a few, but it can be incredibly difficult when dealing with a bank or other corporate entity that is selling a property like that. You don’t get timely responses, sometimes you don’t even get responses that make sense.
As another example, we made an all cash offer on a house a few months back. It was a foreclosure, HUD if I recall correctly. Our offer was countered and they requested 10% down. We didn’t feel that the property was worth that much so we walked away. Later, after the house sold I saw that it actually ended up selling for LESS than we had originally offered in CASH. Just doesn’t make sense to me.
Do you have any thoughts? I would love to hear your experiences and opinion from different areas!